Unleash
the Critical
Thinking.

My AI Ate My Homework

A new book by Richard P. Mislan, PhD

AI can fetch an answer.
Can it make students think?

Synthetic AI characters carry an unfolding story as students investigate, decide, and encounter consequences. CHARACTER provides nine commitments for designing the thinking that experience requires.

Better performance with AI is not always the same as learning students can use on their own. See the research behind the design ↓

My AI Ate My Homework by Richard P. Mislan, PhD. Animated book cover with a dog tugging homework and wagging its tailNEW BOOK!

The dog can have the homework.
Keep the thinking.

FOR EDUCATORSUNIVERSITY LEADERSINSTRUCTIONAL DESIGNERSANYONE RETHINKING LEARNING

AI becomes the people
inside the experience.

The story keeps going.
So does the thinking.

In the approach proposed in this book, synthetic AI characters become the manager, customer, colleague, or stakeholder students need to understand. Each has a role, a perspective, and limits to what they know.

As students ask questions and make decisions, the characters reveal information within their roles, challenge assumptions, and respond as the narrative develops. Decisions lead to consequences that give students new circumstances to investigate. Students return to the people and the evidence, reconsider their explanations, and decide what to do next.

The critical thinking is the student’s work: compare competing accounts, check independent evidence, identify assumptions, weigh tradeoffs, defend a decision, and revise it when the situation changes.

The educator designs the objectives, character boundaries, support, consequence rules, and assessment. AI helps sustain the unfolding experience. Deliberate design keeps students responsible for the judgment.

01 / INVESTIGATE

Hear different stories.

Interview synthetic characters with different knowledge and priorities. Check what they say against records and other perspectives.

02 / DECIDE

Act on your reasoning.

Weigh alternatives and make a recommendation. Explain the evidence, assumptions, and uncertainty behind the choice.

03 / RECONSIDER

The situation responds.

Characters react, consequences unfold, and new information appears. Revisit the evidence, revise the decision, and explain what changed.

Try a short illustration of the decision cycle ↓

Evidence behind
the design.

What matters is the work the learner does.

The book draws on research into active learning, productive failure, and the design of AI-supported interaction. These studies motivate a design question: what should students still have to question, investigate, decide, and explain?

The findings below come from different subjects and settings. They inform the book’s design approach. They do not demonstrate the effectiveness of CHARACTER or its tools as a combined model.

Practice scores and later performanceBastani et al., 2025 · High-school mathematics

In a field experiment involving nearly 1,000 students, a standard chatbot-style GPT-4 tool improved practice scores by 48% relative to the no-AI group. On the subsequent exam without assistance, that group scored 17% lower than the no-AI group.

A second tool used teacher-informed hints and safeguards. It produced large practice gains without the same later decline, but did not show a statistically significant independent-exam advantage over the control group. The percentages are relative score differences, not percentage-point changes.

The design question: Does support help students practice the thinking they will need when the support is gone?

Read the PNAS study ↗
Active learning and productive failureFreeman et al., 2014 · Kapur, 2015

A meta-analysis of 225 undergraduate STEM studies found higher assessment performance and lower failure rates with active learning than with traditional lecturing. The average assessment difference was 0.47 standard deviations.

Productive-failure research examines a sequence in which students first generate and explore possible solutions, then receive structured instruction and consolidation. Under appropriate conditions, this design can support conceptual understanding and transfer. Simply withholding help is not the approach.

The design question: What preparation, challenge, and follow-up instruction will make the effort worthwhile?

Designed AI interactionKestin et al., 2025 · Undergraduate physics

A randomized trial in a Harvard undergraduate physics course compared a purpose-built AI tutor with in-class active learning. Students using the tutor showed greater immediate learning gains while spending less time on the material.

The tutor used a structured sequence and research-informed teaching principles. This result concerns that tutor and those lessons. It does not establish that a general chatbot will outperform classroom instruction or develop higher-order critical thinking in every setting.

The design question: How do feedback, pacing, and the sequence of tasks shape what students learn?

Read the Scientific Reports study ↗

What remains open

Longer-term retention, performance on unfamiliar problems, and outcomes for students with different levels of preparation need further study. The research does not isolate one design feature as the explanation for all these results.

Explore the proposed CHARACTER framework ↓

Before you recommend.
Investigate.

A small decision. An incomplete story.

A fictional business has late orders. The manager wants a recommendation before the next busy week. You can spend the budget on staff training, schedule a system repair, or investigate further.

This short illustration uses prewritten responses and fictional records. In the book’s proposed approach, synthetic AI characters sustain role-based conversation as the story, decisions, and consequences unfold.

1. Hear the accounts. Check a record.

Who would you ask first? What would you check before choosing a solution?

0 of 3 sources opened.

2. Make a provisional recommendation.

You can decide now or inspect another source first. Each choice carries a tradeoff.

The larger design keeps the narrative and character interactions going as students revisit their decisions. See how CHARACTER makes those commitments explicit ↓

Give the experience
some CHARACTER.

A believable character is not a learning design.

CHARACTER is a proposed planning framework informed by learning research. It is not a validated scale, certification, or a proven intervention.

Before an AI character speaks its first line, decide what students will need to think through. CHARACTER connects the roles, unfolding narrative, evidence, and reviewed consequences to the judgment students must practice.

Each commitment asks a specific design question and names the evidence that makes the answer inspectable.

Begin with a decision.

Name the course, what learners already know, one assessable objective, and the decision they will face. Define what students may use, what they must do independently, and what support stays available.

For example: distinguish two competing explanations using independent evidence.

One scenario. Nine design decisions. Choose a letter to change the question, evidence, and worked example.

The shared case: a fictional business has late orders. Students must investigate conflicting explanations and recommend what to do next. These are planning examples, not reported classroom results.

1 / 9

Context

Why act now?

Design evidence

Briefing and trigger

Illustrative planning example: Context

A fictional business has a growing backlog of late orders. Before the next busy week, its manager must decide whether to invest in staff training, repair the order system, or investigate further. The briefing states the deadline and why the decision matters.

A blank commitment is a design question to resolve. More characters are not a substitute for a clearer learning purpose.

Introduced in Appendix A, alongside Chapters 4, 8, and 14. Read the evidence note and its limits.

Explore what’s inside the book ↓

Try one decision.
Start with one page.

A free CHARACTER planning checklist for your next learning experience. Identify the decision, the thinking students must do, and the evidence you will inspect.

No email or account needed. A one-page, fillable PDF you can save, complete, and print.

Open book.
Open possibilities.

Explore the argument, then use the design frameworks and adaptable templates to try a small case of your own.

Practical appendices include the CHARACTER Framework, a synthetic character design card, evidence architecture, a consequence design matrix, a Socratic question map, a Decision Lab blueprint, assessment rubrics, and an implementation roadmap.

I

The answer machine problem

What changes when producing an answer becomes easy?

II

The artificial people in the room

Synthetic colleagues, productive frustration, and questions that teach.

III

Designing the experience

Build situations, evidence, and consequences around learning objectives.

IV

The classroom becomes the laboratory

Explore fictional organizations, Decision Labs, and assessment.

V

The institution that learns

The professor as world builder, and a path toward thoughtful adoption.

Richard P. Mislan

Richard P. Mislan, PhD
Author & educator ↗

Continue the conversation

Richard P. Mislan, PhD, is a Senior Lecturer at RIT’s Saunders College of Business. His teaching connects AI, information systems, and cybersecurity with the judgment students need to explain and defend decisions. His earlier mobile-forensics work at Purdue included curriculum, publications, professional training, and the Mobile Forensics World Conference. Today, that applied-learning perspective informs his work in experiential learning design.

Richard’s work explores a question larger than any one tool: what kind of work helps students become capable of acting when the answer is not already given?

He invites educators to consider how technology can make room for more student judgment. A convincing response from a machine is only a beginning. The educational value depends on what the learner has to question, investigate, decide, and explain next.

This book carries that idea into the design of situations worth entering and work worth doing. These are experiences in which decisions matter, evidence deserves scrutiny, and students remain responsible for their reasoning.

The invitation is to keep asking: What is the learner responsible for? What evidence would make a decision stronger? What should remain possible to revise?

Start with one
learning decision.

Start with a book. Take it into your classroom. See where the questions lead.

Explore the companion destination at Enter the Possible.